College Media Network

A sexist World of Warcraft

Katie Rossomano

For the Daily Titan

Print this article

Published: Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Updated: Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Sexism has spread from the real world to the virtual. The increasingly popular realm of World of Warcraft, a massive multi-player online role playing game, is an Internet community dominated by males.

Females who play it have the option of keeping their gender a secret - as though it is shameful - or enduring harassment if the truth is declared.

Gamers play video games for the same reasons that someone has a couple of beers after a long day at work: to escape reality, if only for a little while. Unfortunately for the women out there, World of Warcraft is no escape when it comes to sexist beliefs which still pollute our society. While WoW is virtual, real people are represented by the characters they play, and they bring their biases with them into "Azeroth," the name of the world in which the majority of the Warcraft series of games is set, according to http://ww.wowiki.com.

For a woman to enter Azeroth, she must first create a character to represent her. At this point, she has the option to play a male character, or sex symbol. The design of female characters, especially the elves (which appear particularly human), are clearly intended to appear "sexy." On the other hand, Blizzard, the company that created WoW, claims that issues such as harassment and sexism will not be tolerated. This creates a paradox, for these 3-D models of the female form encourage sexist viewpoints.

The embarrassment for women who dare to play female characters gets worse as they gather armor, which serves as clothing for the character, during their gaming experience.

The same piece of armor that provides full-coverage and looks tough on a male character will appear provocative on a female. While that piece of armor protects each character from the same amount of damage, it certainly does appear that way on screen.

A woman playing a female character is safe from harassment until she declares herself to be a real-life female, or she joins other gamers on a "vent" channel, which requires the use of a microphone. The microphone is particularly useful in large groups of individuals working together to achieve a particular goal. Yet, it is best if women avoid using one because as soon as their gender is known, they are subjected to ridicule.

It is automatically assumed within the WoW community that female characters are actually being played by "G.I.R.L.s" (guys in real life). This assumption has spawned from the prevalent myth that females do not play WoW, which implies that they are incapable of learning and understanding a relatively complex video game.

While women might be a minority, they are definitely present. When players discover the presence of a real-life woman among them, she becomes subject to comments like "you must be fat, ugly, and acne-ridden." The attacks do not end there. If the woman dares attempt self-defense and say that there is nothing "wrong" with her appearance, then her mental state is assaulted.

In a male-dominated realm, the general consensus is that if a woman does participate then it must be because she is cursed with some appalling characteristic.

Comments

15 comments
Jack
Mon Dec 29 2008 17:32
It's true, you can find sexism in the World of Warcraft online community. Kind of like you can find sexism in schools and workplaces. And it is true that when you find sexist jerks in WoW, they tend to be worse than what you would find IRL. Just like anonymous sexism tends to be worse when found trolling countless online forums catering to any number of interests, hobbies and topics.

I think Ms. Rossomano has identified a legitimate problem. Speaking as an avid WoW player, I think we would be unwise to ignore it. However, I certainly agree with Tan, NBHLiberal, Joe and Stephanie that it is tripe to identify elements within the game itself as the problem. The problem is that we live in a sexist society and that is reflected in any online environment, including the World of Warcraft. Either directly reflected as sexism in the online community or by the necessery efforts to combat it, to keep it out of the community.

It honestly appears that Ms. Rossomano has no idea what the game is like. Starting with her blanket assertion that, "Gamers play video games . . . to escape reality". That is certainly part of it. But an online environment like a MMORPG is more than an escapist game. It is a social context; a very rich environment chat room, so to speak, with activities to participate in, either solo or as a group. There are methods within the game to seek out like-minded individuals (starting with recruiting your friends to play!) and create exclusive groups. The social context becomes what players make it out to be.

There is no in-game requirement to associate with sexist jerks. On the contrary, there are in-games methods to avoid them. Nor is it requisite to create provocative characters. Tan is absolutely right that it is possible to make characters that are not, in any way, sexualized. It is also true that some characters are proportioned in what could be interpreted as sexualized. Or it could be interpreted as idealized beauty. What Ms. Rossomano again misses is that it is true of both the male and female characters. It's just that no one cares when males are objectified, right? Ms. Rossomano is completely off base in her claim that female players are perceived negatively and routinely ridiculed or made to feel unwelcome. All of the male players I know are thrilled to find female players. They go out of their way to make female players feel welcome . . . especially if those players are their wives or girlfriends, but beyond that . . . well, like I said, WoW is a social context. It is made richer by a more diverse population.

My sister-in-law founded a guild. Perhaps because she is an adult woman, it seems to have attracted a larger proportion of adult women than I have run into generally. We definitely want an environment that welcomes that demographic. And we control it. Last night, we kicked one player out for his crass, provocative language. A second voluntarily left when warned his similar language would not be tolerated. Sexism is real. Absolutely. Just like IRL. But even in the World of Warcraft, we can take a stand against it. Just like IRL. Indeed, we should take a stand against it.

tan
Tue Dec 23 2008 21:15
Katie, perhaps you could share some of your sources for this. Not only is this entirely an opinion piece - and not presented as one - but it does not provide any facts to back up the statements. As a CSUF and Daily Titan alum, I am disappointed that this article made it past the editorial staff.
I am female and have played WoW for close to a year now. Yes, many of the female characters are "sexy," if cartoon avatars are your thing, especially the elves. I will even give you the point that they are most likely designed to appeal to male players. However, perhaps you haven't seen the female orcs, taurens or, my favorite, the undead. The undead women are scary and the orcs are downright badass. It is entirely possible to play the game as a female without being a sex object.
I also belong to a great guild in WoW that was started by and is run by a woman. I often play with both men and women in the World. I have not seen the type of discrimination that you write about in this article.
The number of female gamers is growing, and it would be nice to see a well-researched article that explores this and presents different viewpoints, especially from someone in the college demographic.
nonbleedingheartliberal
Tue Dec 23 2008 07:14
It's always nice when a well written article is made completely worthless by being complete and utter bollocks. I've been playing the World of Warcraft for a while now and this is just trash the amount of research that would have been done to write a piece of tripe such as this could be done in an hour of reading the most irrelevant links found in a Google search. The only sexism I have encountered in the game was in my guild in the form of completely insincere jokes and more often than not these jokes were started by the female members of the guild. These players face no discrimination that I have ever experienced and this is not just restricted to my guild a lot of women often say that they are really women and if they don't it is a choice they make and not for any reason related to discrimination. Also concerning the appearance of the characters it begs the question: are movies sexist because they have beautiful people in them? Seriously appearance is not sexist, in reality appearance is choice, to an extent anyways, and people for some reason want to look good, strange eh? People want to be sexy, so would it not be safe to say that given the choice most people would make their avatar look as good as possible too? If woman wants to dress however she wants to it her choice to do so. You say that there is sexist pressure placed on women to dress a certain way well your right there is pressure but it isn't sexist. Yeah some of the pressure comes from men but I would every single cent to my name that more pressure comes from other women. I need someone to explain to me how when women are pressured to do something it’s sexism but when men, who believe it or not face the same pressures, face the same crap it’s not sexism. Next time before ragging on games maybe you should play them and get a real experience of what they are and how much enjoyment a person of any age and of any sex can get out of them.
Joe
Thu Dec 18 2008 13:46
This article is a perfect example of "victim mentality." Woe is me attitude. I feel sorry for when this girl graduates from college and goes to work. Her fellow employees and her bosses are going to have to put up with exaggerated problems all day.

My buddy plays wow and I asked him about this. He said this girl is dead wrong.

Stephanie
Thu Dec 18 2008 13:42
I am a female and have been playing wow since the beta vanilla days. I get just as much respect from my guild as anyone else does. It seems that the writer of this article is either A) has not played the game and is only repeating exaggerated stories about it, or B) got mistreated by one rude person and is labeling everyone as such.

Another thing -- since when is being "sexy" something bad? I wish I could get away with wearing some of the outfits in the game (the santa one comes to mind), but unfortunately calories do bad things in real life. Women are attractive, so why do some "female rights" folks label attractive or sexy as being a bad thing?





Verify you are human: